Nichole Hope Mathis Age: 34 Charges: • Controlled Substance – Possession of Analogues • Larceny $199-$1,000 • Larceny Less Than $200 • Retail Fraud 3rd Degree Bond: • $10,000 PR • $3,500 C/S 10 percent • $3,500 C/S 10 percent
Samantha Marie Peychich Age: 33 Charges: • Controlled Substance – Possession of Methamphetamine/ Ecstasy • Controlled Substance – Maintaining a Drug House Bond: $50,000 PR
Raymond Joseph Scott Sr. Age: 49 Charge: Controlled Substance – Possession of Methamphetamine/ Ecstasy
Gladwin County Sheriff’s Office
Aaron John Thomas Garvie Age: 43 Charges: • Child Support – Failing to Pay/Leaving State • Contractor – Fraudulent Use of Building Contract Fund • Unlicensed Residential Builder Bond: • $5,000 Cash Defendant’s Name Only • $50,000 PR
Justin Michael Stillwagon Age: 21 Charges: • Assault with a Dangerous Weapon (Felonious Assault) • Weapons – Felony Firearm Bond: • $25,000 C/S 10 percent
Troy Willis Garner Age: 58 Charges: • OWI Bond: $50,000 C/S 10 percent
James Robert McCarthy Age: 58 Charges: • OWI Bond: • $7,000 C/S 10 percent
Trever Charles Gottschalk Age: 41 Charge: Larceny in a Building
The following individuals were arrested by the Gladwin County Sheriff’s Office and lodged in the Gladwin County Jail during the time period of March 16 through March 22, 2026....